CONTENTS
HIGHLIGHTS
Credits This report was prepared by Bryant Robey, M.A., and Paula Stauffer, M.H.S.Ward Rinehart, Editor. Stephen M. Goldstein, Managing Editor, Design by Linda D. Sadler. Production by Merridy Gottlieb coordinator. The assistance of the following reviewers is appreciated: Winthrop P. Carty, Patrick Coleman, Cynthia P. Green, Sahar Hegazi, Nash Herndon, Izzat Hijab, M. Tajul Islam, Karungari Kiruga, Philippe Langlois, James McCarthy, Chris McKee, Alice Payne Merritt, Phyllis Tilson Piotrow, Malcom Potts, Jose G. Rimon, II, Peter W. Roberts, Cynthia Salter, Kristina Samson, J. Joseph Speidel, Thomas W. Valente, Clayton T. Vollan, and Edson Whitney. Suggested citation: Ropey, B., Ross, J., and Stauffer, P. Helping the news media cover family planning. Population Reports, Series J, No. 42. Baltimore, Johns Hopkins School of Public Health, Population Information Program, November 1995. This report was made possible by support from G/PHN/POP/CMT, Global, US Agency for International Development, under the terms of Grant No. DPE-A-00-90-00014-00. The opinions expressed herein do not necessarily reflect the views of the US Agency for International Development or the Johns Hopkins University.
Center for Communication Porgrams The Johns Hopkins University School of Public Health Phyllis Tilson Piotrow, Ph.d., Director, Center for Communication Programs and Principal Investigator, Population Information Program Ward Rinehart, Project Director, Population Information Program Anne W. Compton, Deputy Director, Population Information Program, and Chief, POPLINE computerized bibliographic services Hugh M. Rigby, Associate Director, Population Information Program, and Chief, Media/Materials Clearinghouse Jose G. Rimon II, Deputy Director, Center for Communication Programs and Project Director, Population Communication Services, developing family planning communication strategies, projects, training, and materials Population Reports (USPS 063-150) is published four times a year (September, October, November, December) at 111 Market Place, Suite 310, Baltimore, Maryland 21202-4012, USA, by the Population Information Program of the Johns Hopkins University School of Public Health. Periodicals postage paid at Baltimore, Maryland. Postmaster to send address changes to Population Reports, Population Information Program, Johns Hopkins University School of Public Health, 111 Market Place, Suite 310, Baltimore, Maryland 21202-4012, USA. Population Reports is designed to provide an accurate and authoritative overview of important developments in the population field. The opinions expressed herein are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of the US Agency for International Development or the Johns Hopkins University.
This report was made possible by support from
G/PHN/POP/CMT, Global, US Agency for International Development, under the terms of Grant No.
DPE-A-00-90-00014-00. The opinions expressed herein do not necessarily reflect the views of the US Agency
for International Development or the Johns Hopkins University. November, 1995 |
Helping the News Media Cover Family Planning To make informed choices about family planning, women and men need accurate information in the media as well as in the clinic. The media are looking for news important to the millions of people they reach each day. Thus helping the news media cover family planning fully and accurately merits the efforts of every family planning program. Family planning programs often have opportunities to make the news because they affect large numbers of people, reflect changing social attitudes and practices, involve government leaders, and deal with controversial issues. Many journalists, however, know little about family planning, and other topics compete for their time and attention. Most family planning programs, for their part, have made little effort to encourage informative, accurate news coverage. Effective news media relations has many benefits, complementing other communication efforts. What people read, see, or hear in news coverage can lend credibility to family planning and help to make it a legitimate and familiar topic for public discussion. News coverage can inform people about family planning choices and help them ask providers appropriate questions. Skill in media relations can help avoid or dispel rumors, respond to criticism, defuse controversy, and even turn adversity to advantage. News coverage is crucial to engaging policymakers' attention and earning opinion leaders' support. Also, because the news media pay distribution costs, helping journalists cover family planning is a cost-effective way to communicate.
Developing Good Working RelationshipsLike other communication efforts, working with the news media is done best when it is based on a strategy and follows a systematic process. A good strategy seeks opportunities to match the goals and objectives of the organization with the interests of journalists. As in other communication strategies, assessing the needs of the audience—journalists—is important to reaching them effectively. The most important task of media relations is to find newsworthy information and to present it to journalists accurately and in ways that they can use. Most organizations that work well with the news media rely on proven techniques, methods, and materials. These include:
The News Media and
While newspapers reach fewer people than radio and television, nonetheless newspapers attract millions of readers daily in some developing countries—for example, about 22 million in India, 3.7 million in Indonesia, and 3 million in Turkey (71). In the Philippines more than 70% of women read a newspaper at least once a week (54). In Dar es Salaam, Tanzania, 90% of men and 71% of women read a newspaper at least once a week (75).
Working with the news media is important because news coverage is often people's first source of new information. Also, news coverage helps confirm and reinforce the information that people receive about family planning programs from other sources, such as entertainment programs, brochures, field workers, family members, and friends (28). Particularly where the news media are independent of official control, people see them as credible, important sources of information (73). Informing people and encouraging healthy behavior. With their broad reach and powerful influence, the news media can help to improve reproductive health practices. As people are exposed to new information, ideas, and values—such as using contraception to control their fertility—many become increasingly aware and interested and, eventually, some decide to take action. At each stage in this process communication plays a key role (55, 76). News coverage can contribute at each step:
Policymakers follow the news media closely because the news both reflects and shapes popular opinion (52, 63). In many countries the news media set the agenda for public discussion and debate by deciding what issues to cover and how to report on them (65). By drawing a situation to public attention, the news media sometimes even seem to create events rather than just report them (64). Policymakers pay attention to stories with such headlines as:
Working with the news media should be part of the overall communication effort of most family planning and other health-care organizations. Many family planning communication campaigns reach audiences directly, with messages designed to enable and encourage healthful attitudes or behavior. In such campaigns, organizations ideally determine which audiences should be addressed, develop appropriate messages, and decide the channel, format, and timing of the communication (55). In contrast, when working with the news media, organizations do not control the messages. Instead, journalists make these decisions based on criteria of newsworthiness and appeal to their audience. Nevertheless, adding a news media relations component to other communication activities is vital because it can increase their reach and credibility. Moreover, the cost to family planning programs can be modest because the news media pay the production and distribution costs (2, 21).
Building a News Media
"If management thinks of the [news media relations] operation in a small way, then it will occupy a small place in the scheme of things, and its contribution will be small. If management thinks it is important, then it will occupy a prominent place, and its contribution will be significant," explain Scott Cutlip and colleagues (16). Only senior management can ensure that the news media relations function is integrated into the organization and that news media relations staff have the necessary access and resources to interpret the work of the organization to journalists promptly, accurately, and authoritatively (36). Chances of success are greatest if the chief news media relations officer reports directly to the head of the organization.
Typically, most organizations that provide public services, such as family planning programs, include the words "public information" in the title of their news media relations unit. Many private organizations use the term public relations, instead. Their connotations differ:
Public information: Informing the public. Whatever the type of organization, the principles and practice of effective media relations are similar. The basic responsibilities of a news media relations unit are to:
Just as most family planning organizations need news coverage to achieve their communication objectives, the news media benefit from the assistance of family planning organizations. Few journalists specialize in family planning or reproductive health (7). Most face tight deadlines, constant pressure, and difficult working conditions (see sidebar, The Journalist's Working Environment). Organizations can help journalists to identify newsworthy topics, obtain access to sources, and prepare interesting stories. These activities benefit both the journalists and the organizations themselves by generating more coverage and more accurate reporting. Working effectively with the news media is largely an exercise in seeking and supplying useful, factual, and timely information that journalists will consider and use as the basis for their stories. They are most likely to use information that offers a good story, is easy to understand, and arrives at the right time. Developing effective relationships. The key to developing good working relationships with journalists is to establish credibility. Credibility begins with being accurate and honest with the news media at all times (16, 22). Over time, credibility earns the trust of journalists. Once an organization develops a reputation for trustworthiness, journalists are more likely to seek out its staff as sources of fact and opinion, to have confidence in what they say, and to cover their activities (45).
In contrast, attempts to "manage" the news media—for example, by withholding information, issuing self-promotional material, or trying to deny access to an unfriendly reporter—undermine the organization's credibility. As the National Association of Science Writers in the US advises: "In acting as an intermediary between an institution and the media, the public relations person serves that institution best by aiding the flow of news and information rather than by attempting to control it" (45). Mediating differences. In their linking role, public information specialists sometimes mediate differences between journalists and the organization. Adversarial relationships develop from time to time because the interests of journalists differ from those of the organization (16). For example, journalists often seek to reveal sensational or negative aspects of a situation (9), while most organizations seek to avoid controversy. Thus staff may hesitate to be forthcoming, fearing that they will be misquoted or have their work discussed unfavorably in public (45). In some organizations the leadership may expect the media relations staff to prevent journalists from writing or airing negative stories. This expectation is unrealistic, of course, because journalists are beyond the organization's control. Adverse stories may appear no matter how skilled an organization's media relations staff is (see Chapter 9.2, Responding to Adverse Coverage). Also, in some organizations the leadership sometimes asks the media relations staff to publicize events and information that have little news value. This practice, if done regularly, can damage credibility with the news media. When tensions mount, good judgment and experience help media relations staff mediate between the interests of the organization and those of the news media. No matter how difficult the situation becomes, the best policy usually is to remain open, cooperative, and professional.
Developing A Strategy The P Process, which the Johns Hopkins Center for Communication Programs applies in communication projects worldwide, is a useful approach for planning and carrying out communication activities systematically (55) (see illustration below). The P Process was designed for communication projects that address audiences directly, whether the general public, family planning clients, or other groups. Still, the approach also can help organizations working with journalists by making news media relations activities more systematic, focused, and responsive to feedback.
The P Process for systematically planning and carrying out a communication project can apply to working with the news media. Each of the steps of the P Process can be adapted to working with the news media: 1. Analysis. An assessment of the status of the news media and their audiences provides basic information about the news media's ability to help an organization reach its communication objectives. Analysis of coverage in the news media reveals the frequency, accuracy, and quality of reporting on family planning, reproductive health, population, and related topics. Analysis helps organizations learn how the news media, policymakers, and the public view the organization and the issues it deals with. Needs assessment can identify the subjects that interest journalists and the barriers to effective reporting. In Bangladesh, for example, a 1992 assessment of journalists' needs involved in-depth interviews with key editors, reporters, and family planning public information officers and focus-group discussions with rural journalists. The assessment found that journalists were interested in family planning and population issues and thought them important but had limited access to information sources and assistance in covering these topics (34). 2. Strategic Design. A family planning program should decide on the key communication objectives that it seeks to achieve in working with the news media—for example, whether to inform the country's leaders about the importance of reproductive health for the nation, to combat false public rumors, to promote informed choice of methods, or another purpose (76). The more specific the objectives of a news media relations strategy, the better its activities can be focused (19). Programs then should determine the message themes that can best achieve the objectives. Such planning helps ensure that the right materials go to the right people at the right place at the right time (19). 3. Development, pretesting, and production. This step involves pretesting specific messages and materials with the intended audience and revising as indicated to make them more effective. Pretesting obviously is difficult when journalists are the audience, and inappropriate with fast-breaking news stories. Nevertheless, whenever possible, people with experience as journalists should review media relations materials or activities for newsworthiness and effectiveness of proposed formats, writing style, and tone. 4. Management, implementation, and monitoring. Contacting journalists, developing newsworthy ideas and materials, creating events that interest journalists, distributing news releases, preparing useful background information, responding to requests for information, and setting up interviews are among the main activities used to carry out a news media relations strategy. Monitoring the outcome of news media relations activities helps programs to compare accomplishments with objectives and to revise the strategy or its implementation. Setting up a systematic and continual means of studying the news media, primarily by clipping, or cutting, newspaper articles and monitoring newscasts, will help the organization follow the news and see opportunities for obtaining coverage as well as measure results. 5. Impact evaluation. In this stage organizations can review the impact of the news media relations program and apply the lessons learned to planning further activities. In addition to review of clippings, one approach is to survey journalists, policymakers, or the public formally or informally. What story ideas have been used? How accurate have stories been? While it may be difficult to attribute changes directly to news media relations, such evaluation helps to link these activities both to changes in news coverage and to the effects of that coverage on public opinion and knowledge. Planning for continuity. News media relations, like communication in general, is a process. Building good working relationships takes time, and getting results takes persistent effort. Individual journalists come and go, programs change, and new needs arise. Throughout, the public demand for news andinformation persists. A professional approach, high standards, and commitment to the public interest, applied consistently over time, can help an organization meet its communication goals and advance the cause of family planning and good reproductive health.
How To Tell the By finding and supplying journalists with information that fits their criteria for news, you meet their needs and advance your own communication goals (52). Many family planning stories—more than most people think—have potential news value. Here are some examples:
While there is no single definition of news, all news stories contain at least one, and usually several, of the following elements—immediacy, proximity, consequence, and human interest—and often deal with trends, important people, and conflict or controversy (9, 13, 28, 40, 52, 56, 67). Immediacy. To be newsworthy, an event must be new. "Old news is no news," as the saying goes. Immediacy probably is the most important element of news (56). One way to give family planning stories immediacy is to link your organization's activities to a prominent current event, such as the visit of a president, the opening of a clinic, the release of a report, or the achievement of a milestone. Family planning programs can anticipate some events well in advance because they occur on a regular basis—for example, World Population Day, July 11. Others, such as the launch of a new project or service, are within the control of your organization. The release of new survey results or a publication or the introduction of a new contraceptive method also offer immediacy. You can take advantage of these opportunities by being ready—having materials prepared in advance and contacts with the news media well established. Proximity. People tend to be more interested in events near to them than those that happen far away. "Contraceptive methods, the impact of population growth on society—these are new things," Kenyan journalist Hilary Ng'Weno has observed. "The question is whether you can relate them to topical events within your country and hang them on a peg that makes it possible for journalists to use them" (46). Because of the news value of proximity, reporters usually are interested in finding a "local angle" to an international story. Thus international conferences convened periodically by the United Nations on such topics as women's status, population and development, and the environment offer opportunities for organizations to relate these far-away events to local circumstances and people. You can find clients or staff members to be interviewed or point to the local impact of a global issue. Journalists need the local angle at the same time that they are covering the international story, however, not the following week (53). Consequence. The more consequential an event, trend, or issue is to their audience, the more likely journalists are to consider it newsworthy. For example, "if five people in a village migrate to a city, it is hardly news. But if 50 people out of a population of 500 leave their homes in search of greener pastures, it certainly makes a news story" (44). Family planning and population issues often have powerful demographic, economic, social, and environmental consequences that make them newsworthy. Highlight these consequences in a way that people can understand. For example, in the Philippines a major national daily newspaper linked population growth and Manila's traffic congestion in this interesting way:
Why Driving in Metro Manila Is Like Wriggling Through a Sardine Can
Manila. In all the discussions of Metro Manila's traffic problem, one thing is often overlooked by the experts: the basic fact that there are too many people in the metropolis—and too little space to accommodate them. (The Manila Times, February 9, 1995) Striking statistics can capture consequence. For example, Population Reports drew headlines by pointing to the need for condoms in this graphic way: "By rough estimate, condoms were needed in more than 13 billion acts of sexual intercourse in 1990" (39). A good technique is to reduce statistics to a manageable size, as did The Philippine Journal News:
Manila. Three hundred infants die every day in the Philippines not by starvation, disasters, or wars. The top killers are diarrhea, pneumonia, measles, and other easily prevented or treated diseases. (The Philippine Journal News, February 5, 1995) Human interest. Few things are as compelling to an audience as the personal experience of someone like them. Journalists will appreciate interviewing family planning clients, program staff, and officials because such interviews generate human interest—for example, a man who has had a vasectomy, a couple who decided to space their next birth to protect their children's health, or a father who decided that it is just as important for his daughter to go to school as for his son. Trends. Most family planning programs can link their activities to trends in public health, population growth, or the country's social and economic situation. For example, you can show how condom distribution has helped slow the spread of HIV/AIDS, how spacing births has helped to improve children's health, or how a new contraceptive has enabled more women to avoid unintended pregnancies (53). Release of survey findings offers the opportunity to highlight family planning. The Demographic and Health Surveys (DHS), for example, reveal new attitudes, knowledge, and practices about family planning when compared with earlier data. The new findings are especially newsworthy when they contradict commonly held beliefs or provide new evidence of major changes in people's lives. Important people. Big names make news. When a high-level government official takes a public position on family planning, it usually makes the broadcast news and newspaper headlines. When you involve a film star in a program activity, the news media are more likely to cover it. You also can generate news media coverage by asking public figures—political leaders, traditional chiefs, entertainers, socialites, religious leaders, authors, prominent business executives, and sports stars—to endorse your program or support family planning publicly. To do so, monitor the news media to identify sympathetic public figures, contact them, either directly or through a high-level intermediary, and ask them to help you. Offer to help them prepare for their appearance on your behalf (26). Conflict and controversy. Whether you like it or not, your organization probably will become embroiled in a public controversy at one time or another. Often, family planning organizations think that such conflict is always bad for them. In fact, sometimes it can promote informed choice by attracting journalists' attention and providing an opportunity for you to tell your side of a story, thus informing the public and gaining a broad audience.
Tools for Analysis
Collecting and analyzing press clippings. By selectively clipping the major newspapers regularly over a period of months, you can build a file on family planning, public health, and other topics of interest. Here are the basic steps to clipping the newspapers (59):
Over time, this information will reveal patterns that help you to anticipate coverage and to improve it. For example, if a particular reporter is consistently inaccurate, you can present facts that provide a basis for more accurate reporting (2). If a journalist provides family planning with consistent coverage, you could help the journalist by providing more information, scheduling interviews, and arranging site visits. Monitoring radio and television. It is more difficult to analyze radio and television coverage because you must watch or listen to the news and either take notes or obtain and review audio or video tapes. It is worth the effort, however, given the importance of radio and television. Ask stations for tapes of programs that mention your organization or that cover topics of interest. Also, to the extent possible, monitor influential programs that often comment on economic and social issues and programs that you want to air your material so that you can learn more about their formats and interests.
A media list should be as complete as possible, including not only names, addresses, and phone numbers of key contacts, but also each news media outlet's circulation, language, and audience; publisher, key editors, reporters, or program directors; and publication or program deadlines. Also collect as much information as possible about preferred means of contact, copy and photo specifications, and other policies. Collect this information for:
Keep your media list up to date, reviewing it every six months or so. Because journalists change jobs and assignments often, it is important to monitor population and family planning coverage and to be alert to these changes (14). As you come to know journalists personally, you will learn of changes as a matter of course through your contacts with them. Be sure this new information is added to the media list.
Matching Your Message Whatever the medium, all messages for the news media should reflect a key, overall communication goal, or theme, of your organization. This practice helps build a central image and helps send a consistent message—for example, that family planning is important and valued. In effect, instead of presenting many different stories, your organization presents many parts of one story (2).
When radio stations have a variety of program formats appropriate for family planning coverage. These formats include: News. When preparing a story for radio news broadcast, make it as brief as possible. The more you can concentrate your message into capsule form, the more likely it will be used on radio news. Send tapes,news releases, and other materials to the assignment editor, who decides which stories are aired. Radio news relies on the "sound bite"—a short, memorable summary statement that captures attention (2, 53). A good sound bite, which is equivalent of a good quotation in the print media, is difficult to achieve but is an important media relations tool that will help generate coverage. "A bite can compress a group's position in a quick, witty manner—capturing the attention of the media," observe Michael Pertschuk and Philip Wilbur (52). Features. Radio stations sometimes broadcast features that offer a longer look at an issue or profile an interesting person. You can develop or draw the radio station's attention to a feature that reports the personal experiences of clients, a step-by-step bisit to a clinic, or portions of a training seminar on family planning, for example. Talk shows and interviews. Talk shows have become popular in many countries. These offer an opportunity to promote public discussion of family planning and other health issues. Consider approaching talk show producers with program ideas and potential guests, including staff, clients, articulate supporters of family planning, and well-known public figures who are willing to state their views on the air (26). Editorials. The broadcast or radio management's opinion may carry considerable authority with listeners. You can suggest editorials about family planning. Support your case with the facts and the benefits to the audience. Also, If a radio statin takes a different editorial position from the one you advocate, consider responding to it. Many stations will provide air time for opposing opinions. Special events. These are on-the-spot "live" broadcasts of events that have news value—for example, a conference, a cabinet minister's speech, the arrival of a foreign dignitary, the opening of a clinic. Help radio journalists prepare for these events by providing background material in advance, including information on the people involved and what you expect will hapen (67).
The family planning story lends itself to the use of pictures. Whether positive—a counselor helping her client, or a healthy child and mother—or negative—an overcrowded slum or a polluted river—images capture viewers' attention and arouse their emotions. Getting the family planning story reported on television requires thinking visually. As with radio, television presents information quickly, so the message must be clear, pointed, and easy to understand. Many news media relations specialists, however, make the mistake of sending only printed news releases to television stations. To improve chances of coverage, also send photographs, slides, videotapes, charts and graphs, or ideas for filming possibilities along with the printed news release. Good photographs or graphics are often the main reason that a television station will use a story (45). Television talk shows. In some countries television talk shows may offer opportunities to promote family planning. Since television talk shows often try to provoke controversy in order to attract audiences, however, be careful that a particular show is an appropriate forum in which you can air your message clearly and objectively (20, 21).
Feature articles. Many newspapers regularly publish feature articles about family planning and other health-care topics. Possibilities for feature articles can be found everywhere. Here are some feature ideas about family planning, based on questions that many people ask:
Dhaka. When a 38-year-old villager named Anwara picks up her bag of family planning materials and heads down the dusty alleyways of Pirojali, a village of fruit orchards and rice paddies just north of this capital, she is greeted with smiles and waves from many village women.There are three ways to place feature stories in newspapers (67):
When writing a feature article yourself for submission to a newspaper, it is essential to write it as a journalist would, to increase chances of selection. Most features are less immediate than news stories, but you should make the information as timely as possible to interest readers (45). Conflicts resolved, problems overcome, and such human emotions as joy, tenderness, and hope all have a place in the feature story (67). In a feature story the facts unfold throughout the body of the story rather than through the "inverted pyramid" of facts reported in news writing (see sidebar, Essentials of News Reporting). By studying feature stories that appear in the newspapers in which you are interested, you can learn the favored style (67). Also, the following guidelines will help you write features: Lead. A quotation, a provocative question, or a short declarative sentence can make a strong feature lead. For example:
Nairobi. Anne Switi, a 28-year-old marketing executive, is in a dilemma. Anne has to choose between her one-month-old baby and her career. (Daily Nation, October 28, 1992) Drama can make a good feature lead. In another article from the Kenyan Daily Nation, the reporter began a feature about training teachers to become good counselors in this way:
Nairobi. The class is so quiet that one could hear a pin drop as the course participants and facilitators wait expectantly. In comes a "student" sobbing and the "teacher" takes charge in a cool but firm manner that gets respect and obedience. Body. The body of the feature develops, elaborates, and explains the theme. It is best to use only one central theme in a feature. In writing the body, you want to present a problem as drama, show how it can be resolved, and show how the resolution can improve people's lives. Conclusion. Features often conclude with a dramatic climax, a memorable message, a summary of salient facts, or a restatement of the lead for emphasis. The feature story cited above about family planning in Bangladesh ends with this quotation from a senior health ministry official:
"We are already bursting at the seams," Mr. Azizul said. "To think of 160 million people by 2005, and 250 million people by 2030, seems horrifying. But if we can sustain our present successes, I believe we can stay out of the quagmire. In any case, we simply cannot admit the possibility of failure." (The Baltimore Sun, September 25, 1994) Editorials. Sometimes also referred to as an opinion piece, an editorial takes a position, clarifies a point, or urges action. Editorials, which can be written by the editor or publisher of a publication, often mirror viewpoints held by many of their readers (67). How can you generate informed editorials about family planning? Editors do not want to be told what opinions to hold or how to express them, but many do want information upon which to base their opinions. To suggest material for an editorial, gather your facts, organize your information, and then telephone the editor for an appointment or send the material by mail or messenger. You can offer information about demographic trends, the impact of population growth on the economy or environment, the benefits of family planning, and other policy-related topics. You also may offer interviews with organization staff to provide background for editorials. Whether or not an editorial appears as a result of your efforts is up to the editor. If an editorial appears, take time to thank its writer. Even if no editorial appears, you will have informed the editorial writers about family planning, and your effort may result in future editorials. Many newspapers also invite guest editorials, or opinion pieces written by members of the community. This department of the newspaper provides an opportunity for you to raise public awareness and inform policy makers (19, 77). Editors seek well-written guest editorials that discuss current issues, suggest new ideas, and offer fresh views. In many countries guest editorials often discuss family planning and population, both favorably and unfavorably, particularly where some groups oppose family planning. The more controversial the issue, the more likely people are to submit guest editorials to newspapers, and the more likely readers are to be interested in them. Especially where your communication objective involves reaching policy makers and informing public opinion, guest editorials can be a powerful medium. Your purpose should be to inform readers and to provide solutions to problems that they face. Since most readers will not be familiar with your topic, the article should be clearly written, positive in tone, and focus on how your ideas affect people (77). To be effective, keep the editorial short (typically no more than 750 words), deal with a single subject, take a point of view, and support this view with examples or research results. Letters to the editor. Letters to the editor provide a forum for people to express opinions, give reactions, and make rebuttals. Consider writing a letter to the editor to set the record straight after an inaccurate or biased article has appeared; to point out the connection between a news item and family planning issues; to respond to differing points of view; or to praise and elaborate on an article with which you agree (19, 67).Whatever the purpose of your letter, its tone should be polite and restrained, and it should conclude with a positive point of view. Letters to the editor should be brief, clear, to the point, and, above all, accurate. An inaccurate letter not only will create a bad impression but also may lead to a negative response from someone who is correcting your letter. Official letters should be on the letterhead of the organization and should be signed by the director, even though you or someone else may have drafted them. In a public debate you can ask opinion leaders or citizens who support you also to write letters to the editor. Editors often gauge public opinion by the number of letters they receive. Because many radio and television stations keep track of feedback from listeners, letters can be influential there, too, even if they are never mentioned on the air. You can write to radio and television station managers giving your reactions to the programs that they air or to suggest that they run more programs on family planning issues. Advice columns. Advice columns are popular and are often one of the best-read sections of newspapers (26). Readers with questions about topics related to childbearing, reproduction, and personal relationships may know of no other place to find accurate information, or they may prefer to pose their questions anonymously. While many newspapers do not have the resources or expertise to produce a regular advice column on reproductive health, they may be willing to print regular columns prepared by family planning staff. You can suggest the idea to editors, present a list of topics that could be covered, and even provide a sample column. Rural and community newspapers. Rural newspapers are good channels for family planning news. They are written in the local language, and the information is disseminated in cost-effective ways. Sometimes even just a large blackboard in the middle of the village serves as a newspaper (67). Coverage about family planning in the rural news media can help efforts to encourage community support for family planning. Many countries have rural news media. For example, Kenya's Rural Press Project published its first rural paper in 1975. Today, rural papers flourish throughout the country and are expected eventually to reach more than 70% of the rural population(72). In Nigeria in the mid-1980s the president redirected development efforts into the rural areas by establishing, with the assistance of the United Nations Economic and social Commission (UNESCO), Africa's first chain of community-based newspapers, which focused on social issues including family planning (1). To suggest stories for community and rural newspapers:
Developing Materials
Editors use only a small percentage of all releases that they receive. Thus applying news judgment is vital to generating coverage. If you find truly newsworthy events and draw them to the attention of the news media in well-written news releases, you and your organization will gain credibility. If, instead, you flood newsrooms with releases about insignificant events, your credibility will suffer, and journalists will be less likely to pay attention to your material in the future. In the US a study found that news releases that had high acceptance rates compared with others were written in a simpler style, dealt with topics that were interesting to their audience, and focused primarily on the following types of stories: topics in the news, research findings, coming events, and consumer information (43). Because most journalists are under deadline, they favor releases that are well written and so need little work on their part. A news release should be both concise and complete, emphasizing conclusions (45). Provide a strong lead and use the "inverted pyramid" form that journalists use in their own news stories. Use simple, direct language, not jargon. Journalists and their readers are not experts in family planning, health care, or population. Most will not know the meaning of such terms as "total fertility rate," "focus-group discussions," and "contraceptive prevalence. Either explain such terms or use terms that readers will understand. Do not be surprised, however, if your release is not printed exactly as you wrote it. While editors sometimes run a story as received, more often than not they rewrite it, add to it, cut it, or use it as part of a bigger story (26). Appearance and distribution. What you have to say in your release and how you say it are most important, but the appearance and distribution of a press release also affect acceptance. For professional appearance, follow these guidelines (67):
Here are some tips on distributing news releases (10, 19, 45):
Use press kits to tell the family planning story to journalists in a way that they will read and use in telling the story to their audiences. For example, in Nigeria the Family Health Services Project prepared and distributed press kits on family planning and population to more than 1,000 journalists throughout the country. These kits generated more than 300 articles over a 2-year period (37).
Experts lists. What family planning and reproductive health activities and issues are most likely to make the news? New contraceptive technologies, AIDS and other sexually transmitted diseases, demographic trends, population growth, economic progress, health care, and similar subjects often make the news. When they do, journalists want to talk to experts on these topics for background information, reaction, a local angle, statistics, or advice on how to cover the topic (2). Are members of your staff knowledgeable about such topics? Are they willing to talk with journalists? Identify your organization's experts on potentially newsworthy topics. If you think that they would be articulate in talking with the news media, obtain their permission to be included in an experts list for the news media. For use as a reference, the list should be in booklet form that journalists can keep on their desks. The list should be organized by topic, with an alphabetical index by expert's name as well. Give each expert's affiliation and include a paragraph on his or her area of expertise. Provide both daytime and evening telephone numbers if the experts permit. At the beginning of the booklet, describe the purpose of the experts list and include your own name and phone numbers as a general reference. Keep the list up to date because journalists may call you if they cannot reach one of the sources. Issue revised lists periodically, both to update the listings and to reach new journalists. Media resources. Many journalists and family planning organizations alike express a need for journalists to have better access to statistics, background information, and expert opinions on family planning and other reproductive health topics (19, 34). For example, in Brazil a 1995 symposium of journalists and reproductive health experts agreed that journalists are unprepared to cover reproductive health issues, while health professionals do not know how to work with the news media. Participants agreed that, to improve the situation, a better information network should establish links with the press and encourage accurate reporting (3). It need not be costly or difficult to set up a media resource center, a clearinghouse, or a consortium of organizations that journalists can call on for information. The public information officers of these organizations may welcome such opportunities. Develop and distribute to the news media and all health organizations a list of public information contacts in family planning and reproductive health. Regularly update this list. If a journalist calls you for information and your organization is not the best source, refer the journalist to the best source (26). Establishing a repository for population or reproductive health information, whether in an existing information center or within a population-related organization, can encourage informed coverage in the news media. In Peru, for example, an information clearinghouse was established in 1988 as part of an AIDS prevention campaign by the Ministry of Health. The clearinghouse collected and distributed news and research findings about the social, economic, and medical aspects of AIDS. Clearinghouse staff issued news releases, analyzed newspaper coverage of AIDS, and conducted seminars on AIDS for the news media. From August 1988 to April 1989 the clearinghouse sent out 32 news releases, of which the news media used 25 (50). Journalists need to be assured that the information they receive is independent and unbiased. Thus in setting up a center, it may be best to work with a committee of journalists to insure that it meets journalists' needs.
A newsletter is a cost-effective way to release information that is relevant to both external and internal audiences, and it provides regular contact with interested journalists (19). The key to reaching journalists through newsletters is the same as reaching them with other materials—be timely, accurate, and interesting. In writing and editing an organization newsletter, follow the same criteria that a journalist would use. Journalists sometimes even reprint articles from organization newsletters if they are written well, contain news, and have popular appeal. Many newsletters do not meet journalistic criteria. Often they are prepared—or reviewed and rewritten—outside the public information office on the grounds that they are for internal, not external distribution. Like general audiences, however, internal audiences look for information that is objective, well-written, and of broad appeal. If a newsletter meets professional journalistic standards, it will be more interesting to the internal audience and also may attract attention from journalists. Organization newsletters tend to be most successful when their writers and editors think of themselves as professional journalists and the senior staff of the organization see them this way, too.
Making News Interviews, site visits, major publications, news conferences, and briefings also help make news. In addition, providing journalists with opportunities for training or involvement in program activities generates coverage, promotes accurate reporting on family planning, and builds ties between journalists and your organization.
To plan a successful media event, start by seeing it from a journalist's point of view. Decide on the news angle—the aspect that will make the event newsworthy and not just self-promotion. "The more you look like you are trying to get publicity, the more reluctant most journalists will be to give it to you and the less credible your message will be," Pertschuk and Wilbur point out (52). Here are some tips on planning a successful media event:
Reporters usually want to interview people who are directly involved with program activities. The more that you can cooperate with journalists, helping them to meet with program staff and encouraging program staff to make themselves available, the more likely that the resulting stories will be accurate (45). In most cases the public information office is the first place that journalists telephone for information. Many journalists will ask for something in writing (53). As public information officer, you should provide as much information as you can yourself, but do not stretch your own expertise (52). It is best to link journalists directly with experts in your organization—or in other organizations if appropriate—setting up the interviews, providing advance information to the journalist, and preparing the interviewee to answer questions, as necessary. Setting up an interview. Many interviewees, particularly if inexperienced, are fearful and nervous. This is natural because what they say may appear in public in ways that they do not control. Help them prepare. What is the journalist likely to ask? It is acceptable to ask journalists for this information in advance. Most important, interviewees should have two or three "key message points" ready to make—clear, concise summaries of what they want readers or listeners to remember (23). One approach is to follow the "PEW" formula—for "Point, Example, and What it means" (70). That is, in the response briefly summarize the issue raised by the reporter, state how a typical person might be affected, and conclude with an assessment of the impact, a recommendation, or other key message. Since reporters may not ask the questions that elicit precisely the points you want to make, it is a good idea to practice making your points as part of a response to any question. If an interviewee has a few points well prepared and rehearsed, there usually will be an opportunity to make them, whatever questions the reporter asks (23). Some interviewees prepare by holding mock interviews, in which a public information officer poses as the journalist and sometimes tapes and plays back the session for the interviewee. Are the answers complete? Are the points made clearly? Does the interviewee feel comfortable and ready? For on-the-air interviews, interviewees should know who the interviewer will be, what the program is, who is its audience, and whether it will be live or recorded. Will there be questions from a studio audience or over the telephone? For print interviews, the interviewee should be familiar with the publication and its readership and with the journalist's previous work (22). During the interview. Interviews with the news media are an excellent opportunity to establish credibility with reporters and become a trusted source who will be called upon again. At the same time, interviews can be stressful, particularly if the interviewer is trying to lead the discussion into unfamiliar territory or is probing to elicit controversial statements. In a news interview it is important to avoid being pressured or confused by rapid or tough questioning and to make the points that you want to make. Radio and television interviews pose particular challenges. In a radio or television interview, it is vital to keep your responses short and to the point (see Talk shows and interviews in Chapter 6.1). When an interview is taped, it also is important to stick to the points you want to make. Some interviewers keep repeating questions in different ways to elicit a certain response, or your comments may be spliced together later and the interviewer's questions added (23). The more you provide short, precise answers, the more certain that what you intended to say will be used. When being interviewed by a print reporter, you can provide longer answers than on radio or television, and you can go into supporting details and background information. It is wise to be careful about your answers, however, and avoid saying anything that you do not want to appear in the newspaper. Anything that you say could appear in the story, even if you tell the journalist that it is "off the record"—that is, not to be used (see sidebar, Going Off the Record). Here are some tips on how to give a constructive interview:
As public information officer, you play the role of stage manager, or producer, for a site visit. Television crews need space to set up the camera and get a clear shot of the action. The journalists probably want to interview staff and clients during the site visit. You should anticipate such needs and requests and make arrangements in advance. Here are some points to consider in organizing site visits (17):
Since most journalists do not have the time to read long technical reports, you can increase the chances of making news by drawing the major findings, conclusions, and implications to the attention of the news media. A news release accompanying the report should start with a simple statement of its most impressive conclusion (26). The release also should include quotations from the authors, organization directors, or outside authorities to lend credence to its findings. If they want to encourage news coverage of their work, the authors of a study or report themselves should highlight information with potential news value, to the extent possible, as they prepare the report. For example, Population Reports received widespread coverage in the international press with its report, The Reproductive Revolution: New Survey Findings (25, 58, 62). In examining findings of recent surveys and comparing them with earlier data, the authors of the report emphasized the potentially newsworthy aspects of the data implied by the use of the words "revolution" and "new" in the title. Recognizing the potential newsworthiness of the report, the Johns Hopkins Center for Communication Programs public information specialist and the principal author of the report telephoned journalists, including the Associated Press world service reporter, who wrote the initial news story about the report. The Center distributed over 1,000 copies of a news release and the report itself to journalists around the world. The combination of a good story and effective media relations resulted in many articles in leading newspapers as well as radio reports and interviews broadcast around the world. Later, the authors adapted the report as an article that appeared in Scientific American magazine (61), which resulted in another round of news stories and interviews.
Unlike news releases, news conferences offer opportunities for interaction between journalists and representatives of your organization. If you have prominent, articulate, and charismatic spokespeople, they will help attract the interest of the news media (69). In Indonesia, for example, the Equatorial Trilogy, a series of three televised social dramas, was announced at a news conference rather than through a news release because the country's top film directors were involved. The news conference at which they appeared generated more than 100 stories (32). To hold a successful news conference usually requires planning, with particular attention to assuring that journalists attend and that the event itself is newsworthy. Of course, it is not always possible to plan a news conference well in advance, particularly if it is called in response to a controversy (see Chapter 9.3, Turning Adversity to Advantage). Planning. The three most important elements to consider in planning a news conference are who the presenters will be, where the conference will be held, and its timing (19, 26, 69).
Check with government offices, security officials, and others who control access to the conference site to make sure that all reporters can enter the building. If journalists are excluded, it may result in negative publicity, and your efforts will have backfired. In Bangladesh, for example, when security officials refused to admit a reporter to a news conference, the offended newspaper carried a story headlined "Star Reporter Barred," criticizing the organizers for "obstacles to the performance of professional duties by journalists" (Bangladesh Daily Star, May 29, 1994). Journalists usually have the last word. Conducting the news conference. On the morning of the news conference, have enough copies of press kits, news releases, and other materials on hand. Make sure the room is ready for use, that all microphones and electric outlets work. When journalists arrive, greet them and ask them to sign in so that you have a record of who attends. You will use this list later to follow up. If possible, talk with the journalists before they leave and offer your further assistance. Immediately after the news conference, determine who did not attend. There may still be time to interest them in the story (14). How will you know if the news conference was a success? The results will appear almost immediately on the air or in print. If the press conference was poorly attended and few stories resulted, determine the reasons. Do not blame the news media if your news conference does not result in coverage. Perhaps your arrangements were inadequate or your story simply was not newsworthy enough. Another, more important event may have bumped your story. Whatever the reasons, evaluation will help you to do better in the future (14).
A briefing is a good way to inform journalists who are interested in family planning of projects that are being planned or research that is underway. Also, use a news briefing to present your organization's goals and strategies, highlight accomplishments, and discuss policy issues or upcoming events that may not be news yet but that are important for journalists to understand (53). Plan your briefing carefully:
One approach is to offer training that improves journalists' understanding of family planning and reproductive health. Such sessions can vary in length from a single day to two weeks and can vary in audience from top-level editors to news reporters. In Kenya, for example, the African Council on Communication Education, with assistance from Family Health International (FHI), conducted a 2-week training workshop for 24 journalists from East and Southern Africa in 1990. The workshop followed the training curriculum for journalists developed by FHI, later published as Developing Health Journalists: A Training Manual for Improving News Coverage of Reproductive Health (7). Another approach is to bring journalists together with family planning program staff to learn from each other and to explore how the two sides can cooperate to improve cover- age of family planning and reproductive health. Ideally, planning for such workshops should involve journalists themselves to insure that the workshop not only reflects program interests but also meets journalists' needs. In Bangladesh, for example, the Johns Hopkins Center for Communication Programs, the Press Institute of Bangladesh, and FHI collaborated in 1994 on concurrent workshops for journalists and for family planning news media relations staff. The journalists' workshop followed the standard FHI curriculum, while the curriculum for the news media relations workshop was based on the findings of two needs assessments, one among journalists and the other among family planning and other health-care organizations (34, 66). Then, in several joint sessions the participants from the two workshops reviewed common rumors about family planning, practiced holding interviews, and discussed how to work together better in the future. Since then the journalists and news media relations specialists have continued to meet regularly (31). Such workshops usually yield immediate stories. Even more important, they yield long-term benefits by establishing better communication between journalists and family planning programs.
At the Population Reference Bureau (PRB) two projects, Global Edition and Women's Edition, have involved editors from such key publications as Al-Ahram in Egypt, Femina in India, Parents in Kenya, Newsline in Pakistan, and Newswatch in Nigeria in a collaborative project to study and discuss the story possibilities and problems inherent in family planning issues. These editors meet periodically with representatives of international organizations to discuss potentially newsworthy story ideas. PRB also contributes finished pieces, background information, and photographs for the editors to use in their publications. While these projects have focused on the print media, the same approach could apply to gatekeepers in the electronic media (12). Organizations in developing countries can apply this approach to working with senior journalists, keeping in mind that editorial gatekeepers, not family planning programs, decide what issues receive news coverage. Family planning organizations have much to gain by inviting senior editors and broadcasters to a luncheon or other informal venue for an exchange of ideas. "Your overture to a gatekeeper might turn family planning into an excellent, on-going story for all concerned," advises Winthrop P. Carty, associate director for media at PRB (12). Ask the editors how they see family planning stories, what kind of information they could use, and in what form. Such exchanges help interest news media gatekeepers in your activities and establish your organization as a reliable source of accurate information, good interviews, site visits, and other possibilities for stories.
Dealing with Controversy Controversy attracts journalists. Their training teaches that conflict has news value (9). To a journalist, bad news is just as topical and interesting as good news—and often more so (30). In a world where things are expected to go right, journalists look for things that go wrong—the unusual, abnormal, unexpected, and dramatic. Investigative reporting, in which journalists make news by uncovering problems or exposing wrong-doing, can go to lengths that—justly or unjustly—damage the people, organizations, and issues being reported on (35). Many family planning program managers think that the news media should give them unquestioned coverage, support, and endorsement because they are providing good services and not doing anything wrong. Thus they are troubled that journalists so often focus on negative coverage that generates unwanted publicity (68). Although you cannot change what journalists consider news, you sometimes can affect how journalists cover a controversy. Effective media relations can help to head off controversies before they start (21). For example, if reporters trust you, they may ask you to comment on stories generated by the opposition at the time they are being run (19, 26, 30). If the story is baseless, they may decide not to run it. Even journalists who are prejudiced or unfriendly, however, deserve courtesy, respect, and offers of assistance. Your goal is to encourage accurate, objective, fair coverage, not to control access to information or to play favorites. One family planning communication specialist advises that, to deal with persistent attacks, you should step up your efforts to invite journalists to visit clinics and meet clients, send them information about the work of the program and about family planning issues, and telephone them with offers of your assistance in covering medical issues (27). In contrast, warns the US National Association of Science Writers, if you try to obstruct reporters, they may be even more likely to pursue negative stories, since the distrust that you sow may convince them that you are trying to hide something (45).
(1) Study the position of the opposition. Learn the arguments of family planning opponents. What do they object to? What is their motivation? Answering such questions will help you to anticipate their arguments and be ready to respond with arguments of your own or else to seize the initiative by releasing accurate information even before the opposition can release its position (29). (2) Know your own organization's position. Developing clear positions, based on careful research, on major and controversial issues will help to provide responses to hostile questions and criticisms when the need arises. (3) Prepare to act. When a public controversy erupts or a crisis occurs, you must act quickly. Before your organization becomes embroiled in a controversy, have a plan for developing your response, including who should be consulted and who should make the final decision about what is said to the news media (22). In a controversy designate a single spokesperson for your organization who should be available to journalists at all times. No one else in your organization should comment on the controversy. Be ready with a supply of press kits and updated press contact lists. Also, have a list of your constituents whom you will inform when a controversy occurs, including program managers and government officials. If they know about the controversy and understand your position, they will be better able to offer support.
When a negative story appears, the first step is quickly to assess it and its likely impact (26, 67):
How can you turn adversity to advantage? Because controversy makes for good news stories, journalists often are eager to print or broadcast responses to attacks (2). Attacks on your work provide opportunities to refute the opposition, to show the value of your activities, and to demonstrate the widespread support that your organization enjoys. Controversy helps you clarify issues, become known as a source of expert opinion, and reach more people with the facts about family planning. By helping journalists report your side of the story, you not only counterbalance the views of the opposing side but also provide the public with information at a time when many people are likely to be interested. Many people have learned about family planning through news coverage of controversies (29). For example, without controversy the United Nations International Conference on Population and Development (ICPD), held in Cairo in September 1994, might have been of little interest as news. Instead, the news media covered the conference intensively, primarily because the Vatican launched a public attack on positions advocated in the draft document prepared for debate at the conference. The fact that the Vatican strongly advocated an opposing point of view was newsworthy. Journalists around the world began covering the debate almost daily, months before the ICPD itself convened. While many stories focused on the negative views of the opposition, they also included the case for family planning. The controversy attracted thousands of journalists to the conference itself, who otherwise probably would not have covered the event. In Cairo, with the official debate taking place behind closed doors, reporters searched for other stories to tell. Thus topics that usually seem to have little interest as news—for example, women's empowerment, reproductive health, and the need for more family planning information and services—made headlines. Coverage by the news media of the Vatican's attack and the responses to it brought family planning issues to the attention of millions of people. After the conference, for example, a poll by Louis Harris and Associates found that over one-third of adults in the US had heard news about the ICPD (78). Attacks on family planning organizations have had the effect of strengthening support for them and even increased clinic attendance (26). For example, in Colombia the Asociacin Pro-Bienstar de la Familia (Profamilia) turned religious opposition to its advantage by engaging in public debate on the benefits of family planning. In "going public," Profamilia demonstrated overwhelming popular support for family planning and ended up stronger than before the controversy (55). Also, in Ghana, when the government withdrew public service announcements promoting condoms, the major daily newspapers reported the controversy, and many people wrote in support of providing family planning (24). Competition among news media outlets often keeps a controversial story going and can generate more coverage of family planning. For example, in Kenya, when health officials estimated that some 10,000 girls are forced to drop out of school each year because they become pregnant, some journalists wrote about moral decay, while others called for better policies toward youth, and still others criticized the schools (47). Each outlet hopes to attract a bigger audience by reporting unique aspects of a controversy, and reporters look for new angles that allow them to continue covering it. Whatever the situation, the best approach is to remain objective. Resist the urge simply to react emotionally to what your opponents are saying. Instead, take the opportunity to state your own case. Often, for example, framing a family planning issue in terms of its health impact helps to counter attacks made on grounds of emotion or tradition. Focus on providing the facts about how family planning and reproductive health services improve people's well-being. No matter how you decide to present your side of the story, be sure that your statements reflect your organization's basic values, such as everyone's right to make informed choices about using family planning. Help your organization to put its best foot forward—by being positive, responsible, and concerned with promoting better reproductive health and healthier families (2).
Sidebars
|