CONTENTS

         Chapters
  1. Background
  2. Oral Contraceptive Use
  3. Benefits of Oral Contraceptives
  4. Health Risks of Oral Contraceptives
  5. Unresolved Health Issues
  6. Emergency Contraceptive Pills
  7. A Practical Guide to ECP

HIGHLIGHTS

Population Reports is published by the Population Information Program, Center for Communication Programs, The Johns Hopkins School of Public Health, 111 Market Place, Suite 310, Baltimore, Maryland 21202-4012, USA


Volume XXVIII, Number 1
Spring, 2000

Series A, Number 9
Oral Contraceptives

Breast Cancer

The possible role of OCs in the development of breast cancer has been debated for over three decades. Some breast cancers are hormone-dependent, and breast cancer is an increasingly common cause of death among older women, particularly in developed countries. Thus many studies have sought to find out if OC use affects the risk of developing breast cancer (521). In 1996 the Collaborative Group on Hormonal Factors in Breast Cancer published an analysis that pooled epidemiologic evidence from 54 studies in 25 countries (82, 83). Covering over 53,000 women with breast cancer and over 100,000 without breast cancer, these 54 studies constituted about 90% of the epidemiologic evidence available at the time. The analysis examined a great many characteristics of OC use and users.

Findings from the pooled analysis include:

  • Overall, women currently taking OCs or who have quit use within the past 10 years were slightly more likely than nonusers to be diagnosed with breast cancer.
  • Risk was greatest for current users and decreased with time between last use and diagnosis. Relative risk was 1.24 for current users, 1.16 for women who had stopped use within one to four years before diagnosis, and 1.07 for women who had stopped use five to nine years before diagnosis.
  • There was no additional risk for OC users who discontinued use 10 to 20 years before diagnosis. In some subgroups former OC users faced less risk than nonusers.
  • The excess risk of breast cancer diagnoses in OC users was solely for cancers that were localized. OC users actually had a reduced risk of cancers that had spread beyond the breast.
  • Women who used OCs before age 20 faced somewhat higher relative risk, when compared with nonusers of the same age, than women who used OCs later in life.
  • Whether a woman first used OCs before or after she first gave birth did not appear to make much difference.
  • For women with a family history of breast cancer, OC use did not seem to increase risk particularly.
  • Duration of OC use did not affect risk.
  • Data were limited, but risk did not appear to be related to type of estrogen or progestin, and the only dose-related difference was a reduction in breast cancer among women who had used the highest dose pills more than 10 years before (82, 83).
This pattern of findings suggests two possible explanations of a relationship between OC use and breast cancer. First, OCs may promote the growth of an already existing tumor. The observations that relative risk is greatest during and soon after OC use and that duration of OC use has no effect on risk argue that OCs do not initiate new tumors. Second, OC users may simply have more frequent and more careful breast exams than other women, and thus their tumors may be found at an earlier stage. The fact that the entire excess risk of breast cancer diagnosis occurs for tumors that are localized and that OC users actually have a reduced risk of cancers that are spread beyond the breast strongly supports this possibility. The Collaborative Group researchers comment:

The relation observed between breast cancer risk and hormone exposure is unusual, and it is not possible to infer from these data whether it is due to an earlier diagnosis of breast cancer in ever-users, the biological effects of hormonal contraceptives, or a combination of reasons. (82)

The finding that the modest additional risk is greatest during OC use and eventually disappears after a woman stops OCs has important public health implications (521). Because most women use OCs when they are young, and breast cancer is extremely rare at young ages, the number of breast cancer cases attributable to OC use would be quite small. By the Collaborative Group's estimate, among 10,000 European or North American women using OCs from ages 16 to 19, an additional 0.5 cases of breast cancer would be diagnosed in the 10 years after these women quit OC use; among those using OCs from ages 20 to 24, 1.5 additional cases; and among those using OCs from ages 25 to 29, 4.7 additional cases. Because of this age gradient, earlier OC use in a population does not lead to more cancers diagnosed overall (82). Generally, the numbers of additional cases would be smaller in developing countries, where breast cancer is less common (83). By 20 years after stopping OC use, there was no significant difference between women who used OCs at these ages and nonusers in the cumulative number of breast cancer cases diagnosed.

Photo of a parade float promoting social-marketed Nova oral contraceptives in Pakistan.
Population Services International
A parade float promotes social-marketed Nova brand oral contraceptives and injectables in Pakistan.
Since the Collaborative Group's analysis in 1996, OCs and breast cancer continue to be studied. A US study involving 744 breast cancer patients found effects largely compatible with the findings of the Collaborative Group, but for the most part increased risks were not statistically significant (480). A small case-control study in Nigeria found that women diagnosed with breast cancer were more likely to have used OCs. The analysis did not control for other risk factors such as age at first birth, however, and information about duration of use and pill formulation could not be obtained (5). Like the Collaborative Group analysis, the German Breast Cancer Study Group found that the breast tumors of OC users tended to be smaller at diagnosis. OC use did not significantly affect the length of recurrence-free survival or of overall survival, however (405).

Previous | Next
Top of Page | Table of Contents


111 Market Place, Suite 310, Baltimore, MD 21202, USA
Phone: (410) 659.6300/Fax: (410) 659.6266/E-mail: Poprepts@jhuccp.org

Population Reports