CONTENTS
Chapters
- Combined Oral Contraceptives
- Progestin-Only Pills
- Progestin-Only Injectables
- Combined Injectables
- Norplant Implants
- Copper-Bearing IUDs
- Female Sterilization
- Vasectomy
- Lactational Amenorrhea Method
- Natural Family Planning
- Barrier Methods
Published by the Population
Information Program, Center
for Communication Programs,
The Johns Hopkins School of
Public Health, 111 Market
Place, Suite 310, Baltimore,
Maryland 21202-4012, USA
Volume XXIV, Number 2
October 1996 |
Vasectomy
Q.1. Are there any medical restrictions by client's age,
number of living children or required waiting time
for a man to undergo vasectomy?
Age? Number of living children?
Recommendation: No. In terms of safety, there are no
age or number of living children medical restrictions
for men to have sterilization, but both must be
considered during the counseling process to minimize
the potential for regret.
While the client's wishes should be paramount, he
should understand that young age is a risk factor
for regret.
Waiting time?
Recommendation: No. If a man has been counseled and has
chosen a vasectomy, no waiting time should be required.
However, it is often beneficial for the man to have
time to think about his decision.
However, the incidence of regret even with young age at
time of vasectomy remains low. Counseling is important
to minimize the potential for regret.
Rationale: Age and number of living children are not
medical reasons to restrict access to vasectomy
according to WHO Medical Eligibility Criteria (302).
However, age and number of living children are
important considerations for the counseling process.
Clarke and Gregson found that men who requested
vasectomy reversal were younger at the time of
sterilization than controls (41).
Other factors that have been associated with vasectomy
regret are remarriage or a change in partner, death of
one or more children after the procedure, improvement
in financial status, and, more rarely, psychological
problems with infertility or other physical problems.
However, vasectomy has not been shown to physically
cause adverse health effects (see Question 5) (178).
Q.2. Who can provide vasectomies?
Recommendation: Vasectomies can be provided by any
health professional who has been properly trained to
perform a vasectomy. Properly trained doctors, medical
officers, nurses, nurse-midwives, and other medical
personnel with surgical experience can successfully
perform vasectomies.
Rationale: Various types of doctors, including general
medical practitioners, general surgeons, other
specialists (such as obstetrician-gynecologists), and
paramedical professionals can receive training to
perform vasectomy (14).
Q.3. Are back-up contraceptive methods
necessary after a vasectomy?
Recommendation: Yes. Although a man may have
intercourse 2 or 3 days after the procedure if it is
comfortable, a vasectomy is not immediately effective.
The recommendations are for back-up methods to be
used for 12 weeks following vasectomy or at least 20
ejaculations. Where programmatically feasible, a
semen analysis should be performed at that time to
check that the semen no longer contains sperm.
It is important to recognize that a vasectomized man
may still be at risk of acquiring or transmitting STDs
and may need to use a back-up method (e.g., condom)
to protect himself and his partner(s).
Rationale: It may take several months for the vas to
clear the sperm contained in them at the time of
vasectomy. This time varies from man to man. Therefore
a back-up method for pregnancy prevention (e.g.,
condoms, DMPA for partner) will need to be used for at
least 12 weeks or 20 ejaculations (30).
Q.4. What is the appropriate follow-up
schedule following a vasectomy?
Recommendation: Follow-up within 7 days or at least
within 2 weeks is strongly recommended to check sites
of incision, remove any stitches, and look for signs of
any complications. If feasible, a semen analysis can be
performed after 20 ejaculations or 12 weeks to verify
that azoospermia has been achieved.
The client should be encouraged to return promptly if
he has any problems (e.g., bleeding, swelling, fever,
pain) or at any time he has questions or concerns.
Rationale: The follow-up examination should take place
between 7 and 14 days after surgery. Clients should
receive counseling on warning signs and reasons to
return for follow-up.
Q.5. Does vasectomy cause adverse
long-term health effects?
Recommendation: No, based on the weight of available
evidence. Studies have not been conclusive as to a
possible increased risk of prostate cancer. Although
several studies found no association, two studies
found a slight increase in risk.
A large study also found no association between
vasectomy and other health effects including
cardiovascular disease.
Rationale: Based on biological and epidemiological
evidence, it is unlikely that vasectomy causes prostate
cancer or any other long-term health effects such as
cardiovascular disease.
A recent study and two earlier studies also examined
the association between vasectomy and prostate cancer.
Zhu et al. used a population-based case-control design
in a population where vasectomy was common (323). No
association was found. Massey et al. and Sidney et al.
both used a cohort study design. The former used a
retrospective cohort of 10,590 vasectomized men (184),
while the latter used a prospective cohort with a mean
follow-up period of 6.8 years among 5,119 vasectomized
men (249). Neither study found an association between
prostate cancer and vasectomy. Giovannucci et al. found
odds ratios of 1.56 and 1.66, respectively, in two
separate cohort studies (96, 97). However, the biological explanation for the association has not been
accepted by experts as likely (96, 97, 115, 184, 249, 322).
Recommendation: Vasectomy does not affect normal sexual
function. After a vasectomy, the man's body continues
to produce male hormones that help the man to have
erections, sex drive/feeling, and ejaculation. A man
may even feel his sex drive is increased because he
no longer worries about getting his partner pregnant.
Rationale: Vasectomy only involves the occlusion of two
small ducts, not the removal of any glands or organs.
Therefore, it does not interfere with the functions of
the testes—testosterone production and
spermatogenesis (60).
Q.6. Should a vasectomy be considered permanent?
Recommendation: Yes. Although there are procedures to
reverse a vasectomy, the operation is very complex
and expensive and the success rate depends on several
factors such as type of reversal procedure, the physician's experience with the reversal procedure, time
since the vasectomy was performed, the client's sperm
quality and quantity, the anatomical effects of the
original vasectomy, the presence of sperm antibodies,
and the client's partner's fertility.
Although reports have found sperm in the ejaculate in
more than 67% of the men who had undergone vasectomy
reversal, the percent of successes, as measured by pregnancies among their partners, ranged from 16% to 85%,
with over half of the studies reporting that less than
50% of the wives achieved intrauterine pregnancy.
Rationale: A vasectomy reversal is an extremely complex
operation that should be performed by highly trained
and experienced surgeons. Microsurgical techniques
require approximately 40 hours of intensive training
in addition to frequent practice before a surgeon is
proficient. Vasectomy reversal may be performed using
micro- or macrosurgical techniques, each with its own
advantages and disadvantages.
Belker et al. (20) and Fox (88) found that the
fertility rate after vasectomy reversal decreased as
the time between the reversal and the original
vasectomy increased. The fertility rate can also be
affected by postoperative scarring of the lumen, a
lack of sperm in the ejaculate, and possibly the
presence of sperm antibodies (178, 183, 232). |