Ensuring Reliable Supplies
Programs can ensure a reliable supply of injectables,
needles, and syringes by:
- Offering only one or two types of injectable,
- Accurately projecting numbers of users,
- Ordering well in advance,
- Training providers in logistics (ordering and managing supplies),
- Shortening the pipeline—the stops on the route from the manufacturer to the provider; and
- Ordering needles and syringes packed with injectables.
Logistics need to be taken into account in program planning
and coordinated with events that can affect demand such as
communication campaigns and provider training.
Offering only one or two types of injectable. Offering
several injectables increases choice but creates logistical
problems. The decision about which injectables to offer rests on
several factors:
- Source of supply. Most programs obtain injectables from
donor agencies. USAID provides only DMPA, while UNFPA
and IPPF supply DMPA and NET EN. Donors supporting the
same program may supply different injectables;
consultation can ensure that programs offer only the
appropriate number of injectables. The policy of the
Department of Health in the Philippines is to refuse
donors' offers of injectables and other products if
they would be a burden to the logistics system (113).
- Preference of clients. Users may have preferences
based on duration of contraceptive protection or extent
of bleeding changes. For example, the Thai National
Family Planning Program found that NET EN was less
popular than DMPA and thus decided not to offer it
(167).
- Training providers. Providers must be able to counsel
clients about each injectable that they offer.
- Efficiency of the logistics system. To offer
several injectables, programs must be able to
supply clinics with amounts that reflect clients'
preferences. This requires keeping track of the
different types of injectables.
- Cost. The cost of commodities alone—drug, needle,
syringe, and swab—is US$3.88 per couple-year of
protection (CYP) for DMPA and $6.30 per year for
NET EN when given every two months. This
calculation uses estimated average commodity costs
on the international market: $0.92 per dose of
DMPA, $1.00 per dose of NET EN, and $0.05 for
needle, syringe, and swab (195). Cyclofem, at $.45
to $.65 per dose, costs an estimated $5.40 to
$7.80 per year (108). The comparable commodity
cost of OCs is $3.00 per CYP (195). Costs of
service delivery are not included in these
amounts.
- Ease of injection. Providers may find DMPA easier to
inject than the more viscous NET EN. DMPA injection may
be less painful because the needle is smaller (167,
281).
- Providing equipment for different injectables.
Injections of DMPA are given with a 21- to 23-gauge
needle, while the wider-bore 19-gauge needle is better
for NET EN. An injection of NET EN with a needle
appropriate for DMPA is more difficult for the provider
and more painful for the client (281). Both Cyclofem
and Mesigyna may be injected with a 21-23 gauge needle
(223). Logistics managers must be able to ensure that
service sites receive the right needles with each order
(134).
- Keeping track of schedules in community-based
distribution (CBD) programs. Setting up work schedules
may be difficult if field workers are responsible for
several injectables at once (134). Program managers in
Matlab, Bangladesh, decided not to introduce Cyclofem
into the CBD program because of the potential
logistical and scheduling problems (211).
Programs just starting out generally begin with one
injectable. The Philippines, for example, has chosen to offer
only DMPA for the first five years (51). The Mexican family
planning program, which first offered NET EN in 1979, is now
adding Cyclofem (205, 245). IPPF suggests this approach to avoid
logistical problems: provide only one progestin-only injectable,
and, if there is demand, one monthly injectable (138).
Accurately projecting numbers of users. Assumptions that use
will always increase by 10% next year are generally inaccurate.
More accurate estimates can be based on historical data
indicating changes in number of users and numbers of vials
dispensed, on current service statistics, or on surveys of the
population served by the program, which can identify women
intending to use injectables. Such surveys are especially
important for DMPA, use of which may increase now that it is
becoming more available. Also, programs need to anticipate
changes in demand in response to communication campaigns (229,
333).
Ordering well in advance—at least three months and
preferably six months (118). The Family Planning Association of
Sri Lanka, for example, orders a 1-year supply of DMPA, about
100,000 vials, when they have five months of stock remaining (2).
Also, advance orders should be coordinated with communication
campaigns.
Training providers in logistics. In some cases clinics run
out of injectables because clinic staff fail to reorder until
there are no supplies left. Clinic staff can be trained to
collect and use the basic information needed to decide when and
how much to order: average monthly consumption, losses of stock
that has been damaged or whose expiration date has passed, stock
on hand (inventory), and lead time—the time between ordering and
receiving supplies (37).
Shortening the pipeline. Some programs have speeded the
passage of contraceptives from the manufacturer to the provider.
The Philippines Department of Health has removed two levels in
the distribution chain. Contraceptives and other drugs used to
pass from the central warehouse through regional, provincial, and
district warehouses and storerooms before reaching the local
health unit. In the new chain, drugs and supplies move directly
from the central warehouse to the provincial or city warehouse,
saving at least six months (260). Some programs speed delivery by
ordering DMPA shipped by air rather than by sea (55, 114).
Ordering needles and syringes. Packed separately from
contraceptives, needles and syringes may be subject to duties
that have been reduced or eliminated for injectables and other
contraceptives. Delivery of needles and syringes is then delayed
until duties are paid. Packed together, needles and syringes have
the same status as injectables.
To make up for diversion to other uses, programs should
order extra needles and syringes. Some suggest ordering twice as
many needles and syringes as doses of injectable (246).
An efficient logistics system can help providers prevent
transmission of infections. If providers run short of needles and
syringes, they may be tempted to reuse equipment. At the same
time many programs must destroy and dispose of hundreds or
thousands of needles and syringes every day. The national family
planning program in Bangladesh, for example, uses 250,000
disposable needles and syringes every month (177).